Valentine is one of Wyvern Rhadamanthys loyal followers, and protects him from something he regards as insignificant like a Bronze Saint of Athena. He first appeared in Hades’ castle on earth where he fought with Pegasus Seiya but said he would fight him again eventually. When the Bronze Saints had reached Hades’ palace in the underworld called Giudecca, Valentine was ordered to dispose of the Phoenix and Pegasus Saint’s bodies in the icy plains of Cocyutus. Though when Pegasus awoke the Saint said he had Athena’s Cloth with him, and as such Valentine took him out of the ice. The Saint persisted to hold on to the Cloth and eventually retaliated against the Harpy Specter, who was defeated in an instant by hundreds of kicks.